Cut List
Share
All recipessteak sandwich

StovetopAmerican

Next-day steak sandwich

Cold ribeye or strip, sliced thin, crusty bread, mustard or chimichurri. Do not recook it to death.

NY strip

Made it?

15 min · 15 min hands-on

Ingredients

1.5 lb on the fire · ~1.4 lb to the table · 3 plates at 8 oz

  • leftover steak, sliced thin across the grain12 oz
  • rolls or thick bread2
  • mustard, chimichurri, or horseradish
  • onion, optional, cooked in the steak fat1 (1 1/2 lb)

Method

  1. 1

    Slice the steak cold, thin, across. Warm the bread. Warm the meat only if you must — 30 seconds in a pan with fat, not a microwave cycle.

  2. 2

    Sauce. Onion if you have it. Eat over the sink if the roll cannot hold it.

If you don’t have it

  • Ribeye or stripFlank, hanger, or leftover prime rib. Slice thinner on the grainy cuts. Prime rib wants horseradish, not mustard.
  • ChimichurriMustard, horseradish, or the steak fat and onions. The meat is the filling. Sauce is a smear.

Same cook, different day

  • Cheesesteak-ish

    A griddle and onions. Onions in the fat, meat 30 seconds, provolone to melt. Roll.

  • Cold

    You have discipline. Do not warm it. Thin slices, good bread, a hard mustard. Picnic food.

  • Open-face

    The roll will not hold it. Toast, meat, drippings spooned over. Knife and fork.